Pages

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Les Miserables, the musical sensation

SPOILERS APLENTY!

I have been mesmerised about Les Miserables (both book and musical version) for years and years and it's a delight to finally see it gobsmacking the world and receiving such global high praise. That being said, and because I'm nothing if not judgemental about my entertainment, I am now going to vent about it, good and bad, and everything in between.

Generally speaking, the movie is extremely well made, the cast is one casting mistake short of perfect (we'll soon come to that), the sets, make up, costumes, the sound mixing and the nip and tuck of the songs is all very successfully accomplished. For musical lovers there are plenty of small appearances in the movie that make our hearts an extra bit warmer. Like seeing Colm Wilkinson (the original Jean Valjean) playing the bishop or Frances Ruffelle (the original Eponine) playing one of the whores, among others.

I liked that so many things that are forcefully overlooked when turning a 1400 page classic into a musical were still preserved. Gavroche's elephant, the fact that he dies singing to spite the guards, seeing Gillenormand (Marius' grandfather), the change of address from the Rue Plumet to the Rue de L'Homme D'Arme, Fantine selling her teeth, Fauchelevent and the covent, Grantaire waking up in the morning and joining Enjolras to be shot by his side instead of fleeing and overall seeing so many characters that in a live musical would be only nameless extras (and still are, but in this format you can actually see them and recognize them (in case you've read the book or know the story in a bit more depth)).

Also, when filming a musical, usually the songs are recorded first in a studio and then the actors lip sync on set to that previous recording. What makes this movie ground-breaking is that it completely breaks convention by allowing the songs to be recorded on set, so that the actors are actually singing when they're on camera. That gives them much more freedom to act and makes the voice the actual lead (instead of a performer following the orchestra, the orchestra is then following the actor). Of course, it's not always as pretty as some traditional versions because again there is no pre-set to fall back on and not all acting choices are good and also just because something is done differently doesn't mean it's good (or bad). I do believe that this bold move was the right one because we're not exactly aiming at filming another pretty version of Les Miserables, and for the kind of honest and gritty portrait intended this was the best way to go.

It is a shame that the musical (in whatever shape we give it) can never fully portray every little thing that make the novel such a masterpiece. In an alternate Universe where a five hour long musical is possible I would've liked to see a lot that alas will remain unknown to the vast majority of people that lack the time and/or will to tackle the novel. The story of Marius' father, Fauchelevent's story and the whole convent chapter, the Champmatthieu affair, the episode with the Jondrettes at the Gorbeau House, Thenardier and Marius' father in Waterloo, the downfall of Father Mabeuf, all the other Thenardier children, the whole final chapter with Thenardier and Marius when Valjean's true valour shines through, etc, etc. Living in the real world, however, I believe this will never come to pass.

Anyway, onwards to the casting! Hugh Jackman, perfect, flawless, nothing more to add (though I'm pretty sure you can see some bits where he's mentally cursing Colm Wilkinson for all the absurdly high and long notes at the end of most songs). Anne Hathaway - oscar! Raw and uncomfortable, which in this sort of movie is high praise! Mingling beautiful vocals with an honest and heart-breaking performance.

Here I must add something! I've heard people say time and again that said performer sings better than someone else. Fine, but what people often forget is that in a musical is not all about the voice, it's about the overall performance. I've seen people with great voices humbling themselves and "downgrading" their voice in order to be true to their character and to create a dramatic (or comic) effect. Lea Salonga - one of my favourite performers - gave her sweet lovely voice a hysterical edge when portraying Fantine's despair and I love her all the more for it because it made the character so much more real. On the other hand, this also means that actors who are not singers can still be great musical performers. Johnny Depp in Sweeney Todd, or Dame Judi Dench's rendition of Send in the Clowns.

Which brings us to Russell Crowe, the only grave casting mistake on the entire movie (when even the smallest extras are famous in the musical industry). You may say "Well don't be so harsh, he's an actor, not a singer!", which would only enfuriate me all the more since it demonstrates how little Mr Crowe must know of his character, judging by his performance alone. Javert is a binary man. Things are either white or black, right or wrong, there is no in-between. He is a man guided by law alone, not conscience. He is methodical and mathematical. This must be reflected on his singing. The best Javerts I've seen all have great enunciation and are very precise with the musical score. They don't just sing like it's coming straight from the heart, that's for other characters! And even if you were to attempt something different with Javert, at the very least there should be some meaning behind the words being sung (but that I mean feeling and stressing key words for dramatic effect, and not singing like you're reading the phonebook!). Mr Crowe sings like someone trying to spread butter on toast with their voice, which is just the wrong image for the poor police inspector!

Sasha Baron Cohen and Helena Bonham Carter were good but uneventful (and by that I mean not a revelation since they've both done parts that were somehow similar). I would've like Madame Thenardier to be a bit more like Jenny Galloway portrays her, but oh well! Samantha Barks makes the loveliest Eponine, while Amanda Seyfried plays Cosette just as she is - a little bird, an insipid damsel in distress dull as toast (but unfortunately there's nothing to do there, that's Victor Hugo's fault - even though Claire Danes has managed to make her almost interesting in the past). Eddie Redmayne was a decent Marius and then surprised me and took my breath away in Empty Chair at Empty Tables.

And that's most of my venting. Though, if something else must be said, I'd add that even though in this sort of medium a decent amount of cropping is needed (as a cinema audience you don't need to hear a refrain twice and there's a lot that can be implied and so the lyrics don't need to be so obvious) and I've mentioned earlier that is was well done, still I do believe there'd've been some room for improvement; when chopping some verses out you should make sure that what you're left with still rhymes and also some songs were performed in such a natural way that made them sound a bit too much like long stretches of recitative (and I kept waiting for the proper song to start when actually we were already well into it).

But (if anyone is still reading this... if not, tough luck!) don't let me put you off the thing. I'm just picky and a bit of a snob! Go see it (it's only three hours of your life) and see for yourselves. I'm planning to go again, so it couldn't've been that bad ;)

34 comments:

Ruby Lu said...

I read your whole review! I too, saw the stage show in London and was blown away by it and became a bit obsessed with the sound track, playing it endlessly while in the car 'on my own'. When I heard it was going to be made into a film I couldn't wait to see it and thought I'd want to go and see it numerous times. I saw it a couple of weeks ago with my sister and really struggled through the first third of the movie (the singing was no where near the standard of the live show) and was quite painful at times. I really wondered if I was going to be able to stay until the end. It did pick up and the last two thirds of the film was better. My daughter has asked me to take her to see it, which I will, but I'm not really looking forward to sitting through it again. I 'ditto' all your positives about the movie but found Hugh Jackman's renditions quite cringingly tuneless in parts, Amanda Seyfried's singing was painfully high-pitched, Russell Crowe's singing was better than I expected, Samantha Barks and Eddie Redmayne were very good and finally Anne Hathaway was brilliant!

Shafikul Islam said...

So lovely and beautiful post, like it.
I invite to visit my Beauty blog. Thanks!!

Steve Maroney said...

Truly tremendous vocation with the blog. I do reminiscent of your tough occupation and will stop for more post from you as post gave me pleasure and gives some helps to do same work. Thanks a lot…………………………customwritings.ws/custom-essays

cris williams said...

To talk the fact this is a pleasant post concerning this topic. I got an unadulterated solution from here. Also I can refer to you all bestessaywriting.org/essay_writing.php here to get educational helps. Yet will wait for more posts from the blogger. Thanks a lot…….

Madhu Latha (Dogiparthi) Srungavarapu said...

true tribute to the movie...
If you are intrested in visiting India you might like this blog Humara Hindustan
Hi I am madhu these are my works
This blog is here to promote telugu language Teluguvaramandi

jordans 11 space jame online said...

Most of the time, Retro jordan 94 Shoes For Sale people who are in search of the best footwear to buy consider brand AK-47

John Wilson said...

Great post!

I'm going to watch this movie too...

Thank's autor

http://www.paperwritings.com/

vike ay said...

The post is absolutely fantastic. It is really great piece of data.
I like the way you written this content. Pleasure thanks for the share and stuff.proofreading

Lisa Mair said...

This is my first visit to your blog. Today I have got a new site http://hwsolvers.com/programming_project. I am really happy to be here. I am stay tuned here for your next blog..

vike ay said...

I was awaiting for such an article and I have gained some useful information from this site. Thanks for sharing this information.great, like every of her shows. Thanks for jobs.write my essay for me

vike ay said...

To speak the truth this is a nice post concerning this topic. I got a pure solution from here. Also I can refer to you all best writing service here to get educational helps. Nevertheless will wait for more posts from the blogger. Thanks a lot…….

online slots said...

I like saying thanks to the writer around her own endeavours. This lady has an exceptionally amazing webpage whereby associated instructions will come, behaved on survival mode design, with which has enclosed the information village particular attention to be able to the pup. Most click may namnogim writers that happens to be bed-sheet on the net, once more caused by the writer for approximately unrivaled really good.

Nazmul Aoto said...

Truly tremendous vocation with the blog. I do reminiscent of your tough occupation and will stop for more post phd dissertation help from you as post gave me pleasure and gives some helps to do same work. Thanks a lot

Asik09 said...

This is such a great website to search for different opinions of people from all over the world college application essay please visit with my link.I surely hope you will learn and get more knowledge.

dab99 said...

In fact, it should even diminish interest in learning, says homework help with mathin grade school, and there's very little reason to believe that prep is important in high school.

gateway customer care number said...

Wonderful blog & good post.Its really helpful for me, awaiting for more new post. Keep
Blogging!

bank teller said...

If truth be told prosperous content and exceedingly valuable information. I got it my result over here. I exceedingly urge his/her workings with the positive informative information. Thanks a lot…

vike ay said...

Thanks for your great article friend, i get new information, new ideas to do somethings, i hope you will share again, i keep waiting for next post,thanks.http://colibritool.com/

Patryk But said...

CD KEY

KEYGEN

clé CD

CD KEY to

CDKEY to

best Android/iOS games hacks and cheats!

Hacks to games Android/iOS

Blog o kosmetykach

Recenzje kosmetyków

Pielęgnacja włosów

Części do aut

Czesci do aut

Części do samochodów

Czesci do samochodow

Z klinkieru

klinkier

reklamy na blogu

zarabianie na blogu

reklama na blogu

reklamy na blogach

zarabianie na blogu

jak zarobić na blogu

Zarabianie

Zarabianie w internecie

Zarabianie w necie

jak zarobić pieniądze

mlm

sposoby zarabiania

fm group

sprzedam

kupię

handel hurtowy

hurtownia

hurtownie

handel hurtowy

Trade

Free Likes on Facebook

Free Likes

Likes on Facebook

stal hurtowo

stal

pręty stalowe

ściernice

blachy

stal kwasoodporna

metale kolorowe

tworzywa sztuczne

zautomatyzowanie

zautomatyzowanie czynności,procesów

program do automatycznego wykonywania czynności

DEEPA DHIMAN said...

FIND OUT MORE AT
GLOBAL INFOSOFT

Anonymous said...

It is good information

Tutorials and programming help

http://globalproganswer.com/

david hussy said...

world wide web page linen towards unimaginable method United Nations agency needs to be recognized ascribed to its dedicated although to boot worth, initiated by the author for round choosing their own proficiency or even proficiency. last-minute-movers

hamad uzair said...

World Most popular Upcoming Latest cars and vehicles, Latest Mazda Models, Racing Cars, International Sport Cars, Concept Cars, PS-Pod, Strange Vehicles, Nissan, Royce Corniche, Ford Concept Cars, Strange Vehicles, Mercedes and More Sport Cars and Vehicles with Pictures and Info
WorldLatestVehicles.com

hamad uzair said...

Forex Latest News, Forex Trading Tips, latest forex trading business updates, trading updates, forex trading latest news, forex brokers directory, forex brokers list, Dollars news affairs, Stock Markets, stock market news, stock market analysis, technology news, international forex markets, international forex business news and all updates about Forex Trading
ForexAffairs.Com

Mehmet Kelebek said...

BBC inter-city and inter-city cargo storage items, our company is part of the shipping company first comes to mind at the mention of the transport SOME SITE CHARACTERISTICS
Gebze evden eve nakliyat
Şehirlerarası evden eve nakliyat
Şehirlerarası evden eve nakliye
Şehirlerarası nakliyat
Şehirlerarası nakliye
İstanbul evden eve nakliyat
Şehirlerarası evden eve nakliyat
baza
Bazalar
ucuz baza
başlık
bazacı
kaliteli bazalar
Thank you thank you for choosing us

an muti said...

Minecraft is the fastest growing Java game in the Internet history.
Minecraft servers is a server game of favorite players. This is because it allows you to create Minecraft Skins,Minecraft Maps, Minecraft Resource Pack and other creative possibilities. This is a war game that requires fighting against monsters appear at night and survive by fleeing them, provide for the basic needs of you, gather food, wood, etc. Because this game has many options and entertainment graphics should it become popular all over the world.

Minecraft free download is a sandbox game (sandbox) have been shaped independently by Swedish programmer Markus Persson and is then developed and published by Mojang. Full PC version was released in late 2011. In May 2012 game shape, to cooperate with developers 4J Studios, to be released for the XBOX360.

All Minecraft Games the updated version of Minecraft. The creative aspect of the game and building allows players to build constructions from the block in the 3D world working under certain rules. Other activities include exploring the world, collecting resources, working and fighting, minecraft maps, minecraft game, texture pack minecraft, minecraft adventure maps, minecraft skins, minecraft mods

Egypt said...

thanks

devid john said...

Download captain america 2 : www.captainamerica2thewintersoldier.com/

Lisa Batkina said...

Welcome to The Wedding Diary
https://www.facebook.com/TheWeddingDiaryMagazine

http://horoscopodeldia.blogdiario.com/ said...

http://horoscopodeldia.blogdiario.com/

fifa14.vipmmobank said...

For the actual Nintendo wii console You, the net visitor team wanted to absorb in which into the system in a fashion that might goal with each other to the Television screen plus the GamePad, as well as on it's own across the GamePad.
Fifa 14 coins

Cheap Fifa 14 Coins

Adelbert Enriquez said...

You have a nice blog! I love it, I am very entertained and I learned a lot! I will follow all your posts everyday! You are a genius indeed and all of your words are meaningful, I will promote your blog to my friends and I am very sure they will also like your blog!

Hot Artz
Move Igniter

jazz said...

http://sonidos.blogdiario.com/

Customer recommendations for Alaska Fishing Lodges said...

This is a great musical.